Monday, January 18, 2021
  • Login
MooreAmmo.com
  • Home
  • Ammunition
    • Pistol
    • Rifle
    • Rimfire
    • Shotgun
  • Gear
    • Optics
    • Suppressors
    • Accessories
  • Learn
    • Reloading
    • Shooting 101
    • This Months How To
    • Conceal Carry
  • Firearms
    • Reviews
    • Rifles
    • Pistols
    • Shotguns
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Ammunition
    • Pistol
    • Rifle
    • Rimfire
    • Shotgun
  • Gear
    • Optics
    • Suppressors
    • Accessories
  • Learn
    • Reloading
    • Shooting 101
    • This Months How To
    • Conceal Carry
  • Firearms
    • Reviews
    • Rifles
    • Pistols
    • Shotguns
No Result
View All Result
MooreAmmo.com
No Result
View All Result
Home Gear

ATF Admits No Legal Authority For Bump Stock Ruling

September 21, 2019
in Gear, Suppressors
0
ATF Admits No Legal Authority For Bump Stock Ruling
0
SHARES
60
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Show of hands, who has been paying attention to the various lawsuits dealing with the ATF’s reinterpretation of Bump Stocks? Because to be completely honest, I haven’t been paying as much attention as I clearly should have been. In their most recent court filing, the ATF has admitted some truly explosive news. Namely, they concede that they do not have the authority to reinterpret the definition of machine guns in the bump stock ruling under the National Firearms Act (NFA).

ATF Admits No Legal Authority for Bump Stock Ruling

Let’s back up and provide some context. So, on December 26th, 2018, the ATF issued a final ruling on “bump stocks”. A bump-stock is a device that allows an operator of a firearm to simulate automatic fire by muscle power. While previously the ATF had decided that bump-fire or slide-fire stocks were legal devices, they then reclassified them as illegal machineguns. All current owners were ordered to destroy them. If you did not do so, you faced up to 10 years in federal prison.

Naturally, a lot of people became somewhat ticked off that the ATF would seemingly arbitrarily change their ruling to make thousands of Americans potential felons overnight. As a result, many people filed lawsuits. One such lawsuit was filed by the New Civil Liberties Alliance on behalf of plaintiff W. Clark Aposhian.

This Case in Particular

This lawsuit rests on a fairly straightforward presumption. The complaint states that since all legislative powers lie with Congress, the ATF, as a part of the executive branch, cannot reinterpret statutes to mean something else. Since the law regarding machineguns has not changed, bump stocks can’t be reclassified as machineguns.

There are another 30 odd pages of the original complaint, but that’s about the gist of things. Mr. Aposhian is a law-abiding citizen, the ATF told him that bump stocks were legal so he bought one. The filing states that the ATF lacks the authority to reclassify bump stocks, and thus the ATF has violated Mr. Aposhian’s constitutional rights, as well as exceeding its constitutional remit as part of the executive branch.

ATF Bump Stock Ruling Admission – Why Should We Care?

The million-dollar question. Why do we care? Because as of September 18th, the ATF has written a court brief that admits it exceeded its constitutional remit as part of the executive branch. The court filing states specifically that;

The statutory scheme does not, however, appear to provide the Attorney General the authority to engage in “gap-filling” interpretations of what qualifies as a “machinegun”. Congress has provided a detailed definition of the term “machinegun”…

The New Civil Liberties Alliance, on behalf of Mr. Aposhian, quickly filed a for a preliminary injunction. Essentially, as Mr. Aposhian has suffered “irreparable harm” from the deprivation of his lawfully-acquired bump stock, and the ATF (in the opinion of the Plaintiffs) clearly lacks the authority to cause such deprivation, the Final Rule on Bump Stocks should be struck down.

NCLA Brief

ATF’s Brief on the bump stock ruling is behind a login-wall in the PACER system. It can be found in the 10th Circuit Court’s filings, case number 19-4036, Aposhian v. Barr, et al.


This case is not about whether gun control is a good idea. Rather, Mr. Aposhian’s appeal raises key issues about how an agency may create such a ban—that is, whether agency regulations may contradict a statute passed by Congress. The appeal also challenges the notion that a mere interpretive rule can bind third parties, such as owners of bump stocks.

“The bump stock rule made it a new federal crime to own a bump stock, even one purchased with ATF’s prior permission. ATF knows it didn’t have the authority to enact such a law. Instead of defending the rule, ATF now pretends the ban is just a recommendation for the public. NCLA is confident the court will see through ATF’s games and strike down this invalid rule.” —Caleb Kruckenberg, Litigation Counsel

“ATF is caught between a rock and a hard place. The agency lacks legal authority to issue a so-called legislative rule, but a mere interpretive rule is not legally allowed to bind any third parties outside the government. By ordering half a million bump stock owners to surrender their devices—or face prosecution—ATF has acted in a completely unconstitutional fashion. It is high time for the federal courts to put a stop to this regulatory nonsense.”
—Mark Chenoweth, Executive Director and General Counsel

Congress could have passed bipartisan legislation making bump stocks illegal. Instead, ATF has tried to ban them via administrative action in the Bump Stock Final Rule. This Court has a constitutional obligation to strike down ATF’s attempted legislative rewrite. Otherwise, the Executive Branch will usurp Congress’ legislative function in other areas, and the Constitution’s careful limits on how laws are made will be undone.

Previous Post

Forgotten History of Thompson SMG in Secret Police and Army of Soviet Russia

Next Post

NOW HEAR THIS: Best Electronic Hearing Protection From TFB Staff

Benjamin F

Benjamin F

Next Post
NOW HEAR THIS: Best Electronic Hearing Protection From TFB Staff

NOW HEAR THIS: Best Electronic Hearing Protection From TFB Staff

  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
How Much Is Too Much When It Comes To Handloading?

How Much Is Too Much When It Comes To Handloading?

July 29, 2019
Bullet Expansion: Velocity Is The Deciding Factor

Bullet Expansion: Velocity Is The Deciding Factor

July 29, 2019
.45 ACP vs 9mm: Which Is Better?

.45 ACP vs 9mm: Which Is Better?

July 29, 2019
SB Tactical TF1913 Side Folding Triangle AK Brace Now Shipping

SB Tactical TF1913 Side Folding Triangle AK Brace Now Shipping

May 24, 2020
[TFB GUNFEST] Looking Closer At The KelTec P50

[TFB GUNFEST] Looking Closer At The KelTec P50

0
Glock 21SF (Police Trade-In) Review

Glock 21SF (Police Trade-In) Review

0
Reviewing Silencer Shop’s Custom Brethren Armament BAP9 MP5

Reviewing Silencer Shop’s Custom Brethren Armament BAP9 MP5

0
Silencer Shop Authority: Spike’s Tactical Brown Recluse Review

Silencer Shop Authority: Spike’s Tactical Brown Recluse Review

0
[TFB GUNFEST] Looking Closer At The KelTec P50

[TFB GUNFEST] Looking Closer At The KelTec P50

January 18, 2021
GUNFEST GUIDE – Exclusive TFB And TFBTV Coverage Of New Releases

GUNFEST GUIDE – Exclusive TFB And TFBTV Coverage Of New Releases

January 18, 2021
HOT GAT or FUDD CRAP? Mandalor or Pure Fuddlore?

HOT GAT or FUDD CRAP? Mandalor or Pure Fuddlore?

January 18, 2021

[TFB GUNFEST] B&T VP-9 Reborn? The Amazing NEW B&T Station SIX

January 18, 2021

Recent News

[TFB GUNFEST] Looking Closer At The KelTec P50

[TFB GUNFEST] Looking Closer At The KelTec P50

January 18, 2021
GUNFEST GUIDE – Exclusive TFB And TFBTV Coverage Of New Releases

GUNFEST GUIDE – Exclusive TFB And TFBTV Coverage Of New Releases

January 18, 2021
HOT GAT or FUDD CRAP? Mandalor or Pure Fuddlore?

HOT GAT or FUDD CRAP? Mandalor or Pure Fuddlore?

January 18, 2021

[TFB GUNFEST] B&T VP-9 Reborn? The Amazing NEW B&T Station SIX

January 18, 2021

About Us

MooreAmmo.com – Everyone needs Moore ammo!

Browse by Category

  • Accessories
  • Ammunition
  • Conceal Carry
  • Firearms
  • Gear
  • Learn
  • Optics
  • Pistol
  • Pistols
  • Reloading
  • Reviews
  • Rifle
  • Rifles
  • Rimfire
  • Shooting 101
  • Shotgun
  • Shotguns
  • Suppressors
  • Survival
  • This Months How To
  • Tips
  • Uncategorized

Recent News

[TFB GUNFEST] Looking Closer At The KelTec P50

[TFB GUNFEST] Looking Closer At The KelTec P50

January 18, 2021
GUNFEST GUIDE – Exclusive TFB And TFBTV Coverage Of New Releases

GUNFEST GUIDE – Exclusive TFB And TFBTV Coverage Of New Releases

January 18, 2021
  • About
  • Privacy & Policy
  • Contact

© 2019 MooreAmmo.com

No Result
View All Result

© 2019 MooreAmmo.com

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Create New Account!

Fill the forms bellow to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In